Coisa Deus Rick Renner Exploring Theological Cultural Impact
Table of Contents
- Theological and Linguistic Roots of "Coisa de Deus" in Brazilian Evangelicalism
- Evolution of "Coisa de Deus" in Evangelical Hermeneutics
- Comparative Analysis: Denominational Interpretations of *"Coisa de Deus"
- Intersection with Brazilian Folk Religion: Shared Symbolism and Linguistic Blending
- Rick Renner’s Role in Globalizing "Coisa de Deus" Beyond Brazil
- Renner’s Key Platforms for Disseminating "Coisa de Deus" Renner’s global outreach relies on a multi-platform strategy, including authored works, online courses, and international conferences. His primary vehicles for spreading "Coisa de Deus" include: Books: Published under his ministry, Rick Renner Ministries , with titles directly or indirectly referencing the concept. Digital Content: Weekly teachings via YouTube, podcasts, and subscription-based platforms like The Bible Code . Conferences and Seminars: Hosted in the U.S., Europe, and Latin America, often targeting pastors and church leaders. Partnerships: Collaborations with global Charismatic networks, such as the International Coalition of Apostolic Leaders (ICAL) . These platforms allow Renner to tailor "Coisa de Deus" to Western audiences by emphasizing accessibility, practicality, and immediate applicability—qualities that resonate with contemporary evangelical consumerism. Translation and Adaptation Challenges in English-Speaking Contexts The direct translation of "Coisa de Deus" into English poses semantic and theological challenges. While literal translations like "God’s thing" or "God’s business" preserve the original phrasing, they often lack the cultural resonance of the Portuguese idiom. Renner’s adaptations—such as "God’s divine assignment," "God’s supernatural agenda," or "God’s divine purpose" —shift the focus toward individual destiny and divine mandate, aligning with Western theological narratives of personal calling. Examples of Translation Approaches: Original (Portuguese) Literal Translation (English) Renner’s Adaptation Cultural/Theological Shift "Coisa de Deus" "God’s thing" "God’s divine assignment" Individualizes the concept from collective to personal. "Isso é coisa de Deus!" "This is God’s thing!" "This is God’s supernatural agenda!" Adds emphasis on the miraculous and strategic. "Vida como coisa de Deus" "Life as God’s thing" "Life in God’s divine purpose" Frames existence as a preordained mission. Renner’s adaptations often prioritize clarity over cultural fidelity, which can obscure the original Brazilian context—where "Coisa de Deus" frequently carries connotations of national or church-wide destiny, spiritual warfare, or divine sovereignty over outcomes. In contrast, his versions lean toward individual agency and prosperity-driven theology, reflecting the priorities of the Word of Faith movement. Structured Breakdown of Renner’s Central Works on "Coisa de Deus" Renner’s teachings on "Coisa de Deus" are dispersed across multiple works, but the following titles explicitly or implicitly centralize the concept, often redefining it through a prosperity and empowerment lens. 1. The Supernatural Agenda of God (2016) Core Argument: Argues that "Coisa de Deus" represents God’s predetermined supernatural plan for believers, which includes financial prosperity, healing, and victory over adversity. Key Themes: Divine favor as a right rather than a gift. The role of faith declarations in activating "God’s thing." Criticism of "negative" theology that limits God’s power. Renner’s Phraseology: Uses "God’s supernatural agenda" to frame "Coisa de Deus" as an active, ongoing divine strategy for individuals. 2. The Power of the Supernatural (2018) Core Argument: Expands on "Coisa de Deus" as the normative experience of the believer, contrasting it with "natural" limitations. Key Themes: The fivefold ministry’s role in releasing "God’s thing" in churches. Prayer and warfare as tools to align with divine purpose. Case studies of individuals who "activated" their "Coisa de Deus." Renner’s Phraseology: Introduces "the supernatural norm" to suggest that "Coisa de Deus" is not exceptional but expected for all believers. 3. The Divine Mandate of the Church (2020) Core Argument: Applies "Coisa de Deus" to church leadership, arguing that pastors must operate in divine assignment to see supernatural results. Key Themes: Leadership anointing as the key to unlocking "God’s thing" in congregations. Strategic alignment with God’s will through vision casting. Critique of churches that operate in "natural" rather than "supernatural" frameworks. Renner’s Phraseology: Uses "divine mandate" to elevate "Coisa de Deus" from personal to ecclesiastical authority. 4. The Bible Code: Unlocking the Supernatural (2021) Core Argument: Posits that "Coisa de Deus" is encoded in Scripture and can be "unlocked" through specific biblical principles. Key Themes: Biblical "keys" (e.g., faith, confession, seed faith) as tools to access "God’s thing." Generational curses vs. divine blessings as opposing forces. Practical steps to "claim" one’s "Coisa de Deus." Renner’s Phraseology: Frames "Coisa de Deus" as a decodable system, blending Word of Faith prosperity with Brazilian supernaturalism. Theological and Cultural Divergences: Renner vs. Brazilian Evangelical Sources Renner’s reinterpretation of "Coisa de Deus" introduces several key divergences from its traditional Brazilian evangelical framework: 1. Individualism vs. Collectivism Brazilian Context: "Coisa de Deus" often refers to national or church-wide destinies, such as Brazil’s perceived role in global evangelism or the unity of Pentecostal denominations. Renner’s Adaptation: Shifts focus to personal divine assignments, often tied to financial success or leadership influence. 2. Sovereignty vs. Transactional Favor Brazilian Context: Emphasizes God’s sovereign will over outcomes, with "Coisa de Deus" as a divine decree rather than a negotiable right. Renner’s Adaptation: Positions "Coisa de Deus" as a transactional benefit, achievable through faith, prayer, and strategic declarations. 3. Spiritual Warfare vs. Prosperity Gospel Brazilian Context: Often linked to deliverance and exorcism, where "Coisa de Deus" counteracts demonic interference. Renner’s Adaptation: While retaining elements of spiritual warfare, he prioritizes prosperity and breakthrough as primary manifestations of "God’s thing." 4. Humility vs. Authority Brazilian Context: Traditionally associated with humility before God’s will, even in suffering. Renner’s Adaptation: Frames "Coisa de Deus" as a manifestation of authority, where believers "take dominion" over their circumstances. Direct Excerpts from Renner’s Writings and Their Impact Renner’s definitions of "Coisa de Deus" often serve as doctrinal anchors for his teachings, blending Brazilian supernaturalism with Western prosperity theology. Below are key excerpts and their implications: *"God’s supernatural agenda is not a secret plan hidden in the heavens—it is the open, available, and active will of God for your life. When you align with ‘Coisa de Deus,’ you are not just praying for blessings; you are Theological and Doctrinal Breakdown of "Coisa de Deus" : Core Concepts and Doctrinal Alignments The phrase "Coisa de Deus" (lit. "Thing of God" or "God’s Thing") in Brazilian Evangelicalism functions as a theological and spiritual framework that integrates divine sovereignty, spiritual authority, and covenant dynamics. Rooted in a syncretic blend of Pentecostal/charismatic fervor and Reformed theological precision, it emphasizes the active, sovereign role of God in human affairs while framing spiritual engagement as a form of divine partnership. This breakdown dissects its core theological components—divine sovereignty, spiritual warfare, and covenant theology—before examining its doctrinal relationships with Reformed, Calvinist, and Wesleyan traditions. Practical applications in worship, prayer, and devotion are illustrated through sermonic and devotional patterns, while a comparative table maps its biblical and symbolic foundations. Divine Sovereignty and the Ontology of "Coisa de Deus"
- Spiritual Warfare and the "Coisa de Deus" as a Battlefield Concept
- Covenant Theology and the "Coisa de Deus" as a Divine Contract
- Doctrinal Comparisons: "Coisa de Deus" vs. Reformed, Calvinist, and Wesleyan Theologies
- Controversies and Criticisms Surrounding "Coisa de Deus" in Brazilian and Global Evangelicalism
- Primary Criticisms: Legalism, Hyper-Spirituality, and Cultural Appropriation
- Debates and Conflicts Within Evangelical Communities
- Misuse and Distortion in Fringe Groups
The phrase "Coisa de Deus" has transcended Brazilian evangelical circles to become a globally influential theological concept, largely through the teachings of Rick Renner. Rooted in deep historical and cultural traditions, this expression encapsulates divine sovereignty, spiritual warfare, and covenant theology, while also reflecting Brazil’s unique religious syncretism. Its evolution from a niche theological term to a widely debated doctrine underscores the intersection of faith, language, and cultural identity in modern Christianity.
At its core, "Coisa de Deus" represents more than a linguistic curiosity—it is a framework that reshapes how believers perceive divine authority, spiritual authority, and the boundaries between sacred and secular. Rick Renner’s global dissemination of this concept has sparked both admiration and controversy, bridging Brazilian evangelicalism with international audiences while raising questions about cultural adaptation, theological precision, and the risks of misinterpretation. This exploration examines its origins, theological foundations, and the debates that continue to define its role in contemporary Christian discourse.
Theological and Linguistic Roots of "Coisa de Deus" in Brazilian Evangelicalism
The phrase "Coisa de Deus" (God’s thing, or "thing of God") emerged as a central idiom in Brazilian evangelical discourse, blending biblical hermeneutics with vernacular expressions of faith. Its origins trace back to the intersection of Calvinist and Pentecostal traditions, where theological concepts of divine sovereignty and spiritual empowerment were articulated in accessible, colloquial language. The term reflects a broader trend in Brazilian Christianity—particularly among working-class and marginalized communities—to simplify complex doctrines into relatable, action-oriented phrases. Linguistically, it mirrors the Portuguese "coisa" (thing), a versatile term used to denote objects, events, or abstract concepts, which evangelicals repurposed to signify divine will, miracles, or spiritual authority.The phrase’s theological roots lie in Reformation-era doctrines of predestination and divine election, later adapted by Pentecostal movements to emphasize experiential encounters with the Holy Spirit. In Brazil, where evangelicalism expanded rapidly in the 20th century, "Coisa de Deus" became a shorthand for supernatural validation—whether in healing, prosperity, or prophetic utterances. Its linguistic flexibility allowed it to transcend denominational boundaries, from Presbyterian and Baptist circles to Neo-Pentecostal megachurches, where it often denoted charismatic authority or divinely ordained outcomes.
Evolution of "Coisa de Deus" in Evangelical Hermeneutics
The phrase’s development can be divided into three phases: doctrinal formulation (1920s–1960s), charismatic popularization (1970s–1990s), and cultural mainstreaming (2000s–present). Early adoption occurred in missionary movements like the Assemblies of God (AGB), where Pentecostal leaders framed "Coisa de Deus" as a counterpoint to Catholic sacramentalism and Spiritist syncretism. By the 1970s, Neo-Pentecostal preachers such as Estêvão de Almeida and Renato Cardoso (of Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus) repackaged the term to justify prosperity gospel and political activism, linking divine favor to material success and social influence.A key moment was the 1980s televangelism boom, where "Coisa de Deus" became a marketing tool for faith-based enterprises. Preachers like Edir Macedo used it to legitimize television ministries, framing their programs as "Coisa de Deus" to attract followers. Simultaneously, Protestant denominations (e.g., Convenção Batista Brasileira) adopted it to distinguish biblical literalism from Pentecostal excesses, often pairing it with phrases like "a verdadeira Coisa de Deus" (the true thing of God).
Comparative Analysis: Denominational Interpretations of *"Coisa de Deus"
The phrase’s meaning varies significantly across traditions, reflecting divergent theological priorities. Below is a comparative table outlining its usage in Pentecostal, Neo-Pentecostal, and Protestant contexts:| Aspect | Pentecostal (e.g., Assemblies of God) | Neo-Pentecostal (e.g., Universal Church) | Protestant (e.g., Presbyterian, Baptist) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Core Definition | Divine empowerment through the Holy Spirit; often tied to glossolalia (speaking in tongues) and miraculous gifts. | Divine endorsement of prosperity, leadership, and institutional success; frequently linked to tele-evangelism and political campaigns. | Biblical fidelity and doctrinal orthodoxy; may reject experiential claims as heretical or superstitious. |
| Key Textual References | Acts 2:4 ("And they were all filled with the Holy Ghost")1 Corinthians 12 (spiritual gifts) |
Malachi 3:10 ("Bring all the tithes... and prove me now")Mark 11:24 ("What things soever ye desire") |
John 14:6 ("I am the way, the truth, and the life")Romans 10:17 ("Faith cometh by hearing") |
| Cultural Role | Validates personal spiritual experiences; used in avivamentos (revival meetings). | Justifies institutional growth and wealth accumulation; tied to militant evangelism (e.g., street preaching). | Serves as a caution against emotionalism; emphasizes sola scriptura. |
| Syncretic Tensions | May blend with Candomblé metaphors (e.g., "força espiritual" as divine power). | Explicitly rejects syncretism but adopts Umbanda rhetoric (e.g., "forças do bem" vs. "forças do mal"). | Rejects syncretism outright; views folk religion as idolatry. |
| Notable Figures | David Miranda (AGB), R. R. Soares (Igreja Internacional da Graça de Deus) | Edir Macedo (Universal Church), Valdemiro Santiago (Congregação Cristã no Brasil) | Hermisten Maia (Presbyterian), Carlos Osvaldo Cardoso (Baptist) |
Intersection with Brazilian Folk Religion: Shared Symbolism and Linguistic Blending
"Coisa de Deus" occupies a fraught space in Brazil’s religious landscape, where evangelicalism frequently intersects with Afro-Brazilian traditions (Candomblé, Umbanda) and popular Catholicism. While Neo-Pentecostal leaders publicly condemn syncretism, linguistic and symbolic overlaps persist, particularly in vernacular expressions of power. Below are key areas of convergence:-
Divine Agency and "Forças" (Forces):
Evangelicals and Umbandistas alike use "força" (force) to describe supernatural influence, though evangelicals apply it to the Holy Spirit while Umbanda associates it with orixás (deities). The phrase "Coisa de Deus" mirrors Umbanda’s "coisa de santo" (thing of the saint), both signaling sacred authority. For example, a Pentecostal preacher might declare, "Isso é Coisa de Deus!" (This is God’s thing!) while an Umbanda medium might say "Isso é coisa de Oxalá" (This is Oxalá’s thing), using identical syntactic structures. -
Healing and Miraculous Intercession:
Both traditions employ laying on of hands and anointing oils, though evangelicals attribute efficacy to prayer and faith, while Candomblé practitioners invoke orixás or eguns (ancestors). The Neo-Pentecostal emphasis on "milagres" (miracles) parallels Umbanda’s "passes" (passes), which are ritualized acts of spiritual intervention. In rural Nordeste regions, evangelical healers may use phrases like "Deus está fazendo a Coisa Dele" (God is doing His thing) to describe cures, echoing Umbanda’s "O santo está agindo" (The saint is acting). -
Ritualized Authority and Leadership:
Neo-Pentecostal pastors adopt charismatic personas akin to Umbanda leaders (pais-de-santo), using titles like "Apóstolo" (Apostle) or "Bispo" (Bishop) to convey divine mandate

Rick Renner’s Role in Globalizing "Coisa de Deus" Beyond Brazil
Rick Renner’s ministry has played a pivotal role in exporting the Brazilian evangelical concept of "Coisa de Deus" (God’s thing) to international audiences, particularly within the global Charismatic and Word of Faith movements. Through his books, digital platforms, and teaching networks, Renner adapted the phrase into an English-speaking theological framework, often recontextualizing it to align with Western evangelical priorities—such as prosperity gospel themes, divine favor, and supernatural empowerment. His influence has led to the phrase’s adoption in churches, conferences, and online communities across the U.S., Europe, and Africa, where it now functions as both a doctrinal and motivational tool.Renner’s approach differs from traditional Brazilian sources in its emphasis on individual empowerment and material blessing, reflecting the broader trends of the Word of Faith movement. While Brazilian evangelicals often frame "Coisa de Deus" as a collective spiritual destiny tied to national identity or church unity, Renner’s teachings frequently link it to personal breakthroughs, financial prosperity, and divine favor as a transactional right. This shift has sparked debates among theologians, with some praising its evangelistic reach and others critiquing its potential to distort biblical balance.
Renner’s Key Platforms for Disseminating "Coisa de Deus" Renner’s global outreach relies on a multi-platform strategy, including authored works, online courses, and international conferences. His primary vehicles for spreading "Coisa de Deus" include:
- Books: Published under his ministry, Rick Renner Ministries, with titles directly or indirectly referencing the concept.
- Digital Content: Weekly teachings via YouTube, podcasts, and subscription-based platforms like The Bible Code.
- Conferences and Seminars: Hosted in the U.S., Europe, and Latin America, often targeting pastors and church leaders.
- Partnerships: Collaborations with global Charismatic networks, such as the International Coalition of Apostolic Leaders (ICAL).
These platforms allow Renner to tailor "Coisa de Deus" to Western audiences by emphasizing accessibility, practicality, and immediate applicability—qualities that resonate with contemporary evangelical consumerism.
Translation and Adaptation Challenges in English-Speaking Contexts
The direct translation of "Coisa de Deus" into English poses semantic and theological challenges. While literal translations like "God’s thing" or "God’s business" preserve the original phrasing, they often lack the cultural resonance of the Portuguese idiom. Renner’s adaptations—such as "God’s divine assignment," "God’s supernatural agenda," or "God’s divine purpose"—shift the focus toward individual destiny and divine mandate, aligning with Western theological narratives of personal calling.Examples of Translation Approaches:
Renner’s adaptations often prioritize clarity over cultural fidelity, which can obscure the original Brazilian context—where "Coisa de Deus" frequently carries connotations of national or church-wide destiny, spiritual warfare, or divine sovereignty over outcomes. In contrast, his versions lean toward individual agency and prosperity-driven theology, reflecting the priorities of the Word of Faith movement.Original (Portuguese) Literal Translation (English) Renner’s Adaptation Cultural/Theological Shift "Coisa de Deus" "God’s thing" "God’s divine assignment" Individualizes the concept from collective to personal. "Isso é coisa de Deus!" "This is God’s thing!" "This is God’s supernatural agenda!" Adds emphasis on the miraculous and strategic. "Vida como coisa de Deus" "Life as God’s thing" "Life in God’s divine purpose" Frames existence as a preordained mission.
Structured Breakdown of Renner’s Central Works on "Coisa de Deus" Renner’s teachings on "Coisa de Deus" are dispersed across multiple works, but the following titles explicitly or implicitly centralize the concept, often redefining it through a prosperity and empowerment lens.
1. The Supernatural Agenda of God (2016)
- Core Argument: Argues that "Coisa de Deus" represents God’s predetermined supernatural plan for believers, which includes financial prosperity, healing, and victory over adversity.
- Key Themes:
- Divine favor as a right rather than a gift.
- The role of faith declarations in activating "God’s thing."
- Criticism of "negative" theology that limits God’s power.
- Renner’s Phraseology: Uses "God’s supernatural agenda" to frame "Coisa de Deus" as an active, ongoing divine strategy for individuals.
2. The Power of the Supernatural (2018)
- Core Argument: Expands on "Coisa de Deus" as the normative experience of the believer, contrasting it with "natural" limitations.
- Key Themes:
- The fivefold ministry’s role in releasing "God’s thing" in churches.
- Prayer and warfare as tools to align with divine purpose.
- Case studies of individuals who "activated" their "Coisa de Deus."
- Renner’s Phraseology: Introduces "the supernatural norm" to suggest that "Coisa de Deus" is not exceptional but expected for all believers.
3. The Divine Mandate of the Church (2020)
- Core Argument: Applies "Coisa de Deus" to church leadership, arguing that pastors must operate in divine assignment to see supernatural results.
- Key Themes:
- Leadership anointing as the key to unlocking "God’s thing" in congregations.
- Strategic alignment with God’s will through vision casting.
- Critique of churches that operate in "natural" rather than "supernatural" frameworks.
- Renner’s Phraseology: Uses "divine mandate" to elevate "Coisa de Deus" from personal to ecclesiastical authority.
4. The Bible Code: Unlocking the Supernatural (2021)
- Core Argument: Posits that "Coisa de Deus" is encoded in Scripture and can be "unlocked" through specific biblical principles.
- Key Themes:
- Biblical "keys" (e.g., faith, confession, seed faith) as tools to access "God’s thing."
- Generational curses vs. divine blessings as opposing forces.
- Practical steps to "claim" one’s "Coisa de Deus."
- Renner’s Phraseology: Frames "Coisa de Deus" as a decodable system, blending Word of Faith prosperity with Brazilian supernaturalism.
Theological and Cultural Divergences: Renner vs. Brazilian Evangelical Sources
Renner’s reinterpretation of "Coisa de Deus" introduces several key divergences from its traditional Brazilian evangelical framework:1. Individualism vs. Collectivism
- Brazilian Context: "Coisa de Deus" often refers to national or church-wide destinies, such as Brazil’s perceived role in global evangelism or the unity of Pentecostal denominations.
- Renner’s Adaptation: Shifts focus to personal divine assignments, often tied to financial success or leadership influence.
2. Sovereignty vs. Transactional Favor
- Brazilian Context: Emphasizes God’s sovereign will over outcomes, with "Coisa de Deus" as a divine decree rather than a negotiable right.
- Renner’s Adaptation: Positions "Coisa de Deus" as a transactional benefit, achievable through faith, prayer, and strategic declarations.
3. Spiritual Warfare vs. Prosperity Gospel
- Brazilian Context: Often linked to deliverance and exorcism, where "Coisa de Deus" counteracts demonic interference.
- Renner’s Adaptation: While retaining elements of spiritual warfare, he prioritizes prosperity and breakthrough as primary manifestations of "God’s thing."
4. Humility vs. Authority
- Brazilian Context: Traditionally associated with humility before God’s will, even in suffering.
- Renner’s Adaptation: Frames "Coisa de Deus" as a manifestation of authority, where believers "take dominion" over their circumstances.
Direct Excerpts from Renner’s Writings and Their Impact
Renner’s definitions of "Coisa de Deus" often serve as doctrinal anchors for his teachings, blending Brazilian supernaturalism with Western prosperity theology. Below are key excerpts and their implications:
*"God’s supernatural agenda is not a secret plan hidden in the heavens—it is the open, available, and active will of God for your life. When you align with ‘Coisa de Deus,’ you are not just praying for blessings; you are

Theological and Doctrinal Breakdown of "Coisa de Deus": Core Concepts and Doctrinal Alignments
The phrase "Coisa de Deus" (lit. "Thing of God" or "God’s Thing") in Brazilian Evangelicalism functions as a theological and spiritual framework that integrates divine sovereignty, spiritual authority, and covenant dynamics. Rooted in a syncretic blend of Pentecostal/charismatic fervor and Reformed theological precision, it emphasizes the active, sovereign role of God in human affairs while framing spiritual engagement as a form of divine partnership. This breakdown dissects its core theological components—divine sovereignty, spiritual warfare, and covenant theology—before examining its doctrinal relationships with Reformed, Calvinist, and Wesleyan traditions. Practical applications in worship, prayer, and devotion are illustrated through sermonic and devotional patterns, while a comparative table maps its biblical and symbolic foundations.
Divine Sovereignty and the Ontology of "Coisa de Deus"
"Coisa de Deus" operates on the premise that certain realities—whether supernatural manifestations, spiritual breakthroughs, or divine interventions—exist as ontological extensions of God’s sovereignty. Unlike passive or transactional views of divine activity, this concept posits that God’s will is not merely proclaimed but embodied in tangible, experiential ways. Theological underpinnings align with:
- Calvinist Sovereignty: The doctrine of God’s absolute decree (e.g., Institutes 1.17–18) is mirrored in the assertion that "Coisa de Deus" is irrevocable once declared or activated. Rick Renner’s teachings often cite Ephesians 1:11 ("according to the good pleasure of His will") to argue that divine purposes are preordained and unalterable by human effort.
- Wesleyan Agency: While Calvinism emphasizes God’s unilateral control, "Coisa de Deus" in Pentecostal contexts often incorporates Arminian-like responsiveness, where human faith unlocks pre-existing divine realities (e.g., "The Lord has already spoken it; now we align with it").
- Open Theism Critiques: Some Brazilian theologians (e.g., Anderson Freire) argue that "Coisa de Deus" risks conflating divine foreknowledge with fatalism, though proponents counter that it reflects middle knowledge (Molinarism), where God’s sovereign will is contingently tied to human cooperation.
Practical Manifestation:
Renner’s sermons frame "Coisa de Deus" as a decreed reality that requires faith to access, not create. For example, in "The Power of a Decree" (2017), he illustrates this with:
> "When God declares something as His ‘thing,’ it is as if He has already placed it in the spiritual realm—our role is to walk into that reality by faith, not to manufacture it."This aligns with Reformed covenant theology (e.g., Berkhof’s "divine decree" as the foundation of redemption) but diverges by emphasizing immediate experiential appropriation over gradual sanctification.
Spiritual Warfare and the "Coisa de Deus" as a Battlefield Concept
The phrase is frequently deployed in spiritual warfare discourse, where "Coisa de Deus" represents a divine mandate that must be defended against demonic interference. Key doctrinal intersections include:
- Reformed Warfare: John Piper’s "War of Words" (1989) parallels "Coisa de Deus" in framing spiritual conflict as a battle for truth’s supremacy, but Renner’s approach is more kinetic—invoking "Coisa de Deus" as a weaponized declaration (e.g., "This is God’s thing; the enemy cannot touch it").
- Dominion Theology: The phrase echoes Kenneth Copeland’s "words of faith" movement, where divine decrees are treated as spiritual land claims (e.g., "You are declaring your health as God’s thing").
- Charismatic Resistance: Unlike cessationist views (e.g., Wayne Grudem’s rejection of modern miracles), "Coisa de Deus" assumes an ongoing supernatural dimension to faith, akin to Vineyard Movement teachings on "signs and wonders" (1 Cor 12:10).
Symbolic Warfare Tools:
Renner’s devotional literature ("The Power of a Decree") lists practical applications:
- Decrees as Shields: "Coisa de Deus" declarations (e.g., "My marriage is God’s thing") are treated as spiritual armor (Eph 6:16).
- Tabernacle Imagery: The phrase is linked to the Shekinah glory (Ex 40:34–38), suggesting that "Coisa de Deus" is a localized presence of God’s manifest power.
- Blood Covenant: Some Brazilian teachers (e.g., Esther de Almeida) tie "Coisa de Deus" to covenant anointing, arguing that divine declarations are sealed by Christ’s blood (Heb 9:15–22).
Doctrinal Tension:
While Reformed theology would caution against magical thinking in warfare (e.g., R.C. Sproul’s warnings on "name-it-claim-it" theology), "Coisa de Deus" proponents argue it reflects Jesus’ authority declarations (e.g., "Your faith has made you whole"—Mark 2:5). The key distinction lies in whether "Coisa de Deus" is a passive trust (Reformed) or an active proclamation (Charismatic).
Covenant Theology and the "Coisa de Deus" as a Divine Contract
The phrase functions as a covenantal shorthand, implying that God’s declarations are binding agreements between Himself and believers. Three covenantal frameworks are relevant:
1. Reformed Covenant Chain:
- Works Covenant (Creation): "Coisa de Deus" as God’s original design (Gen 1:28–30).
- Redemption Covenant (Christ): "Coisa de Deus" as Christ’s finished work (Eph 1:7).
- Grace Covenant (Church): "Coisa de Deus" as the believer’s inheritance (Gal 3:29).
Critique: Some Reformed scholars (e.g., Michael Horton) argue this risks legalism, as it frames faith as a transaction rather than trust.2. Dispensationalist Nuances:
- Teachers like David Wilkerson use "Coisa de Deus" to distinguish between age-specific divine purposes (e.g., "The Church Age is God’s thing now").
- Contrast with Amillennialism: "Coisa de Deus" is eternal, not tied to dispensational timelines.
3. Pentecostal/Charismatic Covenant:
- Abrahamic Lineage: "Coisa de Deus" is inherited through faith (Gal 3:14), not ethnicity.
- New Covenant Dynamics: The phrase is tied to Jeremiah 31:33 ("I will put My law in their hearts"), suggesting "Coisa de Deus" is internally authored by the Holy Spirit.
Practical Covenant Rituals:
Renner’s "Decree Prayer" model treats "Coisa de Deus" as a covenantal renewal:
- Written Declarations: Believers write divine promises (e.g., "My finances are God’s thing") and "bind" them to their faith.
- Corporate Anointing: Churches use "Coisa de Deus" in anointing services, where leaders declare blessings over regions (e.g., "Brazil is God’s thing").
- Sacramental Parallels: Some equate "Coisa de Deus" with communion (1 Cor 10:16), arguing that divine declarations are consumed in faith.
Doctrinal Comparisons: "Coisa de Deus" vs. Reformed, Calvinist, and Wesleyan Theologies
Doctrinal Framework Alignment with "Coisa de Deus" Key Divergences Biblical Anchor Calvinist Sovereignty High (divine decree as foundation) Rejects human co-labor in declaring "Coisa de Deus"; emphasizes monergism. Eph 1:4–5; Rom 9:16 Reformed Covenant Theology Partial (covenant structure but not experiential) Warns against works-righteousness; stresses sanctification over declaration. Gal 3:21; Heb 8:6 Controversies and Criticisms Surrounding "Coisa de Deus" in Brazilian and Global Evangelicalism
The concept of "Coisa de Deus" (God’s Thing) has sparked significant debate within evangelical circles, both in Brazil and internationally. While proponents emphasize its role in fostering divine alignment and spiritual authority, critics argue that its application has led to legalistic tendencies, cultural appropriation, and distortions of core gospel principles. The controversies often revolve around its perceived rigidity, the blurring of biblical boundaries, and its association with prosperity theology in fringe interpretations. Below, key criticisms, historical conflicts, and cases of misuse are examined, alongside responses from Brazilian evangelical leaders.
Primary Criticisms: Legalism, Hyper-Spirituality, and Cultural Appropriation
Critics of "Coisa de Deus" frequently highlight three interconnected concerns: legalistic enforcement, hyper-spiritual detachment from reality, and cultural appropriation of indigenous spiritual practices. These critiques stem from observations of how the concept has been operationalized in specific contexts, often diverging from its intended emphasis on divine order.Legalism and Ritualistic Enforcement
The rigid application of "Coisa de Deus" principles—such as mandatory prayer protocols, dietary restrictions, or dress codes—has been accused of imposing burdensome rules that overshadow grace. For instance, some pastors and teachers have framed adherence to these practices as a prerequisite for spiritual authority, creating an environment where non-compliance is equated with rebellion against God. This aligns with broader evangelical debates on legalism, where works-based spirituality risks undermining the freedom found in Christ (Galatians 5:1).Hyper-Spirituality and Detachment from Practical Theology
A second criticism targets the concept’s tendency to prioritize spiritual atmosphere over practical discipleship. Critics argue that an overemphasis on "Coisa de Deus" can lead to a neglect of social justice, biblical ethics, and engagement with secular systems. Some pastors have been accused of using the concept to justify withdrawal from civic participation or political discourse, framing worldly involvement as incompatible with divine alignment. This mirrors historical tensions in evangelicalism between transformationalist (engagement with culture) and separatist (avoidance of culture) theologies.Cultural Appropriation and Syncretism
The origins of "Coisa de Deus" in Brazilian Pentecostal and Charismatic traditions have raised questions about its relationship with indigenous spiritual practices, particularly in Afro-Brazilian religions like Umbanda and Candomblé. While proponents argue that the concept is distinctly Christian, critics point to linguistic and ritual overlaps, such as the use of terms like "força espiritual" (spiritual force) or the invocation of "divine protection" in ways reminiscent of animistic traditions. This debate intensified in the 1990s and 2000s, as "Coisa de Deus" spread beyond Brazil, where cultural contexts lack the same historical ties to these traditions.
Debates and Conflicts Within Evangelical Communities
The adoption of "Coisa de Deus" has not been uniform across evangelical denominations, leading to high-profile conflicts, especially in Brazil. Below are key examples where the concept became a focal point of theological and denominational disputes.The 2004 Assemblies of God (Brazil) Controversy
In 2004, the Assemblies of God (AG) in Brazil faced internal divisions over the teaching of "Coisa de Deus" after a regional conference in São Paulo. A group of pastors, including Pastor Valdemiro Santiago, promoted the concept as essential for church growth, arguing that failure to implement it would result in spiritual decline. Critics within the AG, such as Pastor João Marcos de Oliveira, countered that the teachings bordered on legalism and lacked biblical precedent. The conflict led to a formal investigation by the AG’s national leadership, culminating in a public retraction from some proponents while others doubled down on the concept’s validity.The Rick Renner and Bethel Church Association
Rick Renner’s global dissemination of "Coisa de Deus" principles through The Man in the Mirror Bible Institute and partnerships with Bethel Church (Redding, CA) introduced the concept to non-Brazilian audiences. However, this association also sparked backlash. In 2018, Dr. Michael Brown, a prominent Messianic Jewish scholar, criticized Renner’s teachings in a series of articles, arguing that the emphasis on "divine order" risked replacing biblical authority with subjective spiritual experiences. Brown specifically cited Renner’s alignment with Bethel’s "New Apostolic Reformation" (NAR) leanings, which some evangelicals associate with extreme manifestations and unorthodox theology.The 2017 Brazilian Evangelical Forum Debate
During the III Brazilian Evangelical Forum in Curitiba, "Coisa de Deus" was a contentious topic in panel discussions. Pastor Augusto Zangrandi, a Reformed theologian, publicly challenged the concept, stating:
> "Coisa de Deus" has become a theological placeholder for practices that lack clear biblical foundation. When a pastor tells his congregation that a certain prayer posture or worship style is the only way to please God, it is no longer about faith—it is about human tradition masquerading as divine mandate."*This debate highlighted the divide between Charismatic/Pentecostal and Reformed/Evangelical perspectives on spiritual authority. While Charismatic leaders like Pastor Estevam Hernández defended the concept as a tool for revival, Reformed voices argued it introduced works-based spirituality.
Misuse and Distortion in Fringe Groups
While "Coisa de Deus" remains a mainstream teaching in many Brazilian churches, fringe interpretations have emerged, particularly in health-and-wealth gospel circles and extreme manifestation movements. These distortions often conflate the concept with prosperity theology or claim divine endorsement for unorthodox practices.Overlap with the Health and Wealth Gospel
Some televangelists, such as Pastor Ed René Kivitz (of the now-defunct IURD Church), have blended "Coisa de Deus" with prosperity gospel teachings, arguing that financial blessing is a direct result of maintaining "divine order." In a 2012 sermon, Kivitz stated:
> "If you want God’s financial provision, you must align your home, your finances, and your worship with Coisa de Deus. Tithe not just because the Bible says so, but because it is the way God operates."This fusion led to accusations of exploitation, as some followers were pressured to give excessive donations under the guise of spiritual obedience. The Brazilian Public Ministry (MPF) investigated several cases where churches used "Coisa de Deus" principles to justify coercive fundraising, though legal action was limited.
Extreme Manifestation Movements
In the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) and Kingdom Now circles, "Coisa de Deus" has been repurposed to justify contesting spiritual territories and engaging in supernatural warfare rituals. For example:
- Pastor João de Deus, a controversial figure in Brazilian NAR circles, taught that "Coisa de Deus" required binding and loosing demons in public spaces, including government buildings. His followers claimed divine authority to disrupt political events under the pretense of "restoring divine order."
- In the United States, some NAR-affiliated ministers have used "Coisa de Deus" to promote extreme fasting protocols (e.g., 40-day water fasts) as mandatory for spiritual breakthrough, leading to health crises among congregants.
ASCII Flowchart: Progression from Positive Adoption to Controversial Application
┌───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ COISA DE DEUS: EVOLUTION IN EVANGELICALISM │
├───────────────────┬───────────────────┬───────────────────┬───────────────────┤
│ 1970s-1990s │ 2000s-2010s │ 2010s-Present │ Fringe Distortions│
│ (Emergence) │ (Globalization) │ (Mainstream Debate)│ (Extreme Uses) │
├───────────────────┼───────────────────┼───────────────────┼───────────────────┤
│ - Born in │ - Adopted by │ - Criticized by │ - Blended with │
│ Brazilian │ Rick Renner, │ Reformed/ │ Prosperity │
│ Pentecostal │ Bethel Church, │ Evangelical │ Gospel │
│ circles as a │ NAR movements │ leaders (e.g., │ │
│ revival tool"Coisa de Deus" stands as a testament to how theological ideas evolve beyond their cultural origins, carrying with them layers of meaning that resonate—or clash—with diverse Christian traditions. From its humble beginnings in Brazilian evangelicalism to its global adoption through Rick Renner’s influence, the concept has become a lens through which believers examine divine sovereignty, spiritual warfare, and the nature of covenant. While its practical applications in prayer, worship, and devotion offer profound spiritual insights, the controversies surrounding its interpretation highlight the delicate balance between theological rigor and cultural adaptation. As this discussion demonstrates, "Coisa de Deus" is not merely a phrase but a living dialogue between faith, history, and the ever-shifting landscape of global Christianity.
Leave a Comment
Comments are moderated before appearing. The data you submit is processed according to the Privacy Policy of Ns2.