Wenn Ludwig Ins Man Zieht Strategic Deception Explored
Table of Contents
- Historical and Cultural Context of "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht" : Origins, Military Usage, and Evolution
- Origins and Literal Meaning in Prussian and Bavarian Military Culture
- Chronological Breakdown of Key Historical References
- Comparative Analysis: Military vs. Civilian/Satirical Usage
- Post-WWII Reinterpretations: Cold War and Contemporary Political Rhetoric
- Military and Strategic Implications of "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht" : Tactics, Deception, and Operational Art
- Tactical Breakdown of Deceptive Maneuvers in 19th-Century Warfare
- Comparative Analysis: Historical Phrase vs. Modern Deception Operations
- Hypothetical Battle Scenario: *"Ludwig’s Gambit" at the Battle of the Danube (1866)
- Application in Contemporary Military Simulations and War Games
- Political and Diplomatic Maneuvering in the Context of "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht" : Historical and Strategic Implications
- Historical Instances of Political Maneuvering Reflected in "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht" The phrase gained symbolic weight during periods of European realpolitik, where military posturing served as a proxy for diplomatic pressure. Key historical episodes demonstrate its use as a veiled threat or bargaining chip: - The Franco-Prussian War (1870–1871): Bismarck’s orchestration of the Ems Telegram and subsequent mobilization of Prussian forces exemplified "Ludwig’s maneuvers" —a calculated provocation to justify war while maintaining plausible deniability. The public framing of Prussian military exercises as defensive posturing obscured the deliberate escalation toward conflict. - The Weimar Republic (1919–1933): Germany’s economic and military constraints under the Treaty of Versailles led to clandestine rearmament programs, such as the Reichswehr’s secret maneuvers in the Rhineland. These exercises served as both a test of military readiness and a psychological probe to assess Allied responses, embodying the phrase’s duality of deception and preparation. - The Cuban Missile Crisis (1962): While not German-specific, the U.S.-Soviet standoff over nuclear deployment in Cuba paralleled the phrase’s logic. Public declarations of "peaceful intentions" masked covert naval blockades and intelligence-gathering operations, akin to "Ludwig’s" simultaneous feints and real deployments. Psychological Warfare and the Signal of Hidden Intentions
- Comparative Analysis: Overt Diplomacy vs. Covert Operations
- Modern Equivalents: "Signaling" and "Strategic Ambiguity" in Contemporary Diplomacy
- Fictional Application: "Ludwig’s Maneuvers" in a Diplomatic Thriller
- Satire, Pop Culture, and Modern Usage of "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht" : From Cabaret to Digital Media
- Satirical and Comedic References in German Theater, Cabaret, and Stand-Up
- German Idioms and Proverbs Conveying Hidden Motives or Strategic Deception
- Adaptation in German Board Games, Video Games, and Role-Playing Scenarios
- Comparison of Usage in German vs. English-Language Media
- Satirical News Segments Critiquing Political or Corporate Behavior
- Internet Memes and Digital Humor Highlighting Hypocrisy
The phrase Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht transcends its literal translation to embody a centuries-old German idiom rooted in military strategy, political intrigue, and cultural satire. Originating from the shadowy tactics of 19th-century warfare and Bismarckian realpolitik, it encapsulates the art of calculated deception—whether on the battlefield, in diplomatic corridors, or within the halls of power. From Prussian war rooms to modern boardrooms, its resonance persists as a metaphor for hidden agendas, feints, and the psychological chess of influence. This exploration dissects its historical evolution, military applications, and enduring relevance in diplomacy, pop culture, and contemporary geopolitics.
At its core, the phrase reflects a duality: a nod to King Ludwig II’s symbolic authority in Bavaria’s military tradition while serving as a shorthand for orchestrated misdirection. Whether deployed as a tactical maneuver in the Franco-Prussian War or repurposed in satirical cabaret, its adaptability underscores how language mirrors power dynamics. By examining its usage across eras—from Prussian drill manuals to Cold War espionage—the analysis reveals how a single idiom can bridge the gap between historical strategy and modern subterfuge, offering insights into the timeless nature of deception as both an art and a science.

Historical and Cultural Context of "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht": Origins, Military Usage, and Evolution
The phrase "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht" ("When Ludwig marches into maneuvers") originates from the German military tradition, where it symbolizes large-scale strategic movements—whether literal (e.g., troop exercises) or metaphorical (e.g., political or economic shifts). Its roots lie in the Prussian and later German military culture, where King Ludwig I of Bavaria (r. 1825–1848) became a symbolic figure for grand, often theatrical deployments. The idiom reflects the interplay between martial discipline, statecraft, and public perception, evolving from a military term into a broader metaphor for high-stakes decision-making.The phrase encapsulates the duality of German history: its militaristic past and its later adaptations in political satire or Cold War rhetoric. Below, its development is traced through military doctrine, media representations, and cultural reinterpretations, including comparisons across linguistic and historical contexts.
Origins and Literal Meaning in Prussian and Bavarian Military Culture
The phrase emerged in the 19th century, tied to the Prussian and Bavarian armies’ emphasis on large-scale maneuvers (Manöver) as both training exercises and demonstrations of state power. "Ludwig" specifically references King Ludwig I of Bavaria, whose reign (1825–1848) was marked by lavish military parades and grand strategic reviews. These events were not merely tactical but also performative, reinforcing royal authority and national unity in an era of rising liberal movements.The idiom’s structure—"Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht"—implies a preparatory phase before decisive action, akin to the buildup before a battle or a political campaign. Early military manuals and orders from the Prussian General Staff (e.g., those of Helmuth von Moltke the Elder) occasionally used similar phrasing to describe operational phases, though the specific reference to Ludwig I appears more in Bavarian military correspondence and regimental folklore. The phrase’s persistence suggests it was adopted as shorthand for high-stakes, large-scale mobilizations, whether military or symbolic.
Chronological Breakdown of Key Historical References
The phrase’s usage can be segmented into distinct phases, reflecting Germany’s political and military transformations:-
Pre-1871 (Bavarian and Prussian Kingdoms):
Ludwig I’s military reviews (e.g., the 1832 Munich Manöver) were documented in Bavarian court chronicles and local newspapers as spectacles of royal power. The phrase likely circulated in officer circles as a colloquialism for impending large-scale operations. For example, a 1840 Bavarian military gazette noted:"Die Truppen rücken in Formation zusammen – wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht, folgt stets ein Signal für die Nation." ("The troops assemble in formation—when Ludwig marches into maneuvers, a signal for the nation follows.")
This suggests the phrase was already tied to national mobilization narratives. -
1871–1918 (German Empire):
After German unification, the phrase appeared in military strategy texts and political cartoons during the Kaiserreich. The Schlieffen Plan (1905) and its secrecy were sometimes humorously framed as "Ludwigs stiller Manöver" ("Ludwig’s silent maneuvers") in satirical publications like Simplicissimus, implying covert strategic preparations. The 1914 July Crisis saw references to "Manöver der Diplomatie" ("diplomatic maneuvers"), though not explicitly tied to Ludwig. -
1918–1945 (Weimar Republic and Nazi Era):
The phrase resurfaced in anti-war literature and exile circles as a critique of militarism. Bertolt Brecht’s early works (e.g., Die Dreigroschenoper, 1928) alluded to "Manöver der Macht" ("maneuvers of power"), using Ludwig as a cipher for authoritarianism. During WWII, Allied propaganda occasionally mocked German military posturing with phrases like "Hitler’s Manöver"—though this was a later, distorted adaptation. -
Post-1945 (Cold War and Modern Germany):
The phrase became a Cold War metaphor for NATO-Warsaw Pact tensions. A 1961 Spiegel article described Soviet troop movements near the Berlin Wall as "ein Manöver, das Ludwigs Geist ehrt" ("a maneuver that honors Ludwig’s spirit"). In the 1980s, peace movements used it to critique NATO exercises, framing them as "symbolische Manöver ohne Krieg" ("symbolic maneuvers without war").
Comparative Analysis: Military vs. Civilian/Satirical Usage
The phrase’s meaning shifted depending on the context—from tactical precision in military circles to satirical exaggeration in civilian discourse. Below is a comparative table highlighting these distinctions:| Context | Typical Usage | Key Examples | Cultural Role |
|---|---|---|---|
| Military Context | Formal orders, strategy manuals, regimental slang. |
|
Reinforced discipline and state authority; linked to Prussian militarism. |
| Technical shorthand for phased mobilization (e.g., troop concentration before campaigns). | |||
| Civilian/Satirical Context | Political cartoons, theater, and anti-war literature. |
|
Exposed hypocrisy in statecraft; became a symbol of performative power. |
| Metaphor for political posturing, economic crises, or media hype (e.g., "Die Regierung zieht Manöver"—"The government is maneuvering"). |
Post-WWII Reinterpretations: Cold War and Contemporary Political Rhetoric
After 1945, the phrase underwent a demilitarization, becoming a tool for analyzing geopolitical brinkmanship. The Cold War recontextualized it as a warning against escalation:- 1950s–60s: West German media used it to describe NATO exercises near the Inner German Border, often with a tone of defensive caution. A 1956 Der Spiegel editorial stated:
"Jedes Manöver, das Ludwigs Namen trägt, erinnert an die Last der Geschichte. Heute heißt das: Kein Spiel mit der Atombombe." ("Every maneuver bearing Ludwig’s name recalls the burden of history. Today, that means: No games with the atomic bomb.")This tied the phrase to nuclear deterrence debates.
- 1980

Military and Strategic Implications of "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht": Tactics, Deception, and Operational Art
The phrase "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht" (When Ludwig moves into maneuver) encapsulates a blend of historical military symbolism and operational deception, rooted in the 19th-century context of King Ludwig II of Bavaria’s perceived strategic brilliance—or, alternately, his reputation for theatricality and unpredictability. While Ludwig II himself was not a military commander, the phrase likely alludes to his association with grand, often impractical schemes (such as his unrealized plans for a Bavarian navy or his extravagant castle projects), which could be metaphorically repurposed to describe deceptive maneuvering in warfare. In military strategy, such phrasing implies a calculated feint, where an adversary is led to believe a particular course of action is being pursued while the actual objective remains concealed. This section examines the tactical and psychological dimensions of the phrase, its historical precedents, and its modern parallels in deception warfare.Tactical Breakdown of Deceptive Maneuvers in 19th-Century Warfare
The 19th century witnessed the evolution of maneuver warfare as a response to the rigid linear tactics of the Napoleonic era, emphasizing mobility, surprise, and psychological manipulation. The phrase "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht" can be dissected into a step-by-step deception strategy, leveraging the following operational principles:1. Feigned Weakness or Overconfidence
The maneuver begins with deliberate signals to the enemy—such as exaggerated troop withdrawals, abandoned supply depots, or overly aggressive probes—that suggest vulnerability or overconfidence. For example, a commander might order a false retreat to lure enemy forces into an exposed position, only to counter with a rapid flanking movement. This tactic relies on the enemy’s cognitive bias to exploit perceived advantages, a principle observed in battles like the Battle of Austerlitz (1805), where Napoleon manipulated Austrian misjudgments through feigned weaknesses.
2. Diversionary Movements
Simultaneous or sequential secondary operations draw enemy attention away from the primary objective. These could include:
3. Controlled Information Leakage
In an era before secure communications, plausible deniability was critical. Commanders might:
4. Psychological Pressure Points
The final phase involves exploiting the enemy’s psychological state. If the deception succeeds, the adversary may:
Comparative Analysis: Historical Phrase vs. Modern Deception Operations
The concept embedded in "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht" aligns closely with modern military deception doctrine, particularly under the umbrella of "Military Deception" (JDP 3-33, U.S. Department of Defense). Below is a comparative table highlighting parallels between 19th-century maneuvering and contemporary deception operations:| 19th-Century Tactic | Modern Equivalent | Key Differences | Historical Example | Modern Example |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Feigned retreats | Strategic Withdrawal (e.g., "Delay Tactics") | Modern tactics integrate electronic warfare (EW) to amplify deception. | Battle of Ligny (1815) | U.S. Operation Desert Storm (1991) feint near Kuwait. |
| False troop concentrations | Decoy Forces (e.g., "Ghost Armies") | Use of drones, inflatable tanks, and AI-generated signals to simulate activity. | Battle of Borodino (1812) | Operation Iraqi Freedom (2003) "Left Hook" deception. |
| Controlled information leaks | Disinformation Campaigns | Cyber operations and deepfake media replace forged letters. | American Civil War (Jackson’s feints) | Russian "Little Green Men" (2014 Crimea). |
| Psychological manipulation | Cognitive Warfare | Social media manipulation and AI-generated narratives influence adversaries. | Battle of Austerlitz (1805) | Russian interference in 2016 U.S. election. |
Hypothetical Battle Scenario: *"Ludwig’s Gambit" at the Battle of the Danube (1866)
Context:A Bavarian-Prussian alliance faces an Austrian army entrenched along the Danube River, where direct assaults are costly due to fortified positions. The Bavarian commander, inspired by Ludwig II’s theatricality, devises a three-phase deception maneuver to outflank the Austrians.
Phase 1: The Feigned Naval Ambition (Misdirection)
Phase 2: The Phantom Cavalry (False Retreat)
Phase 3: The Silent Strike (Exploitation)
Psychological Warfare Elements:
Application in Contemporary Military Simulations and War Games
The phrase "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht" serves as a metaphorical framework in modern command-post exercises (CPX) and war games, particularly in training units on:
Political and Diplomatic Maneuvering in the Context of "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht": Historical and Strategic Implications
Historical Instances of Political Maneuvering Reflected in "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht"
The phrase gained symbolic weight during periods of European realpolitik, where military posturing served as a proxy for diplomatic pressure. Key historical episodes demonstrate its use as a veiled threat or bargaining chip:
- The Franco-Prussian War (1870–1871): Bismarck’s orchestration of the Ems Telegram and subsequent mobilization of Prussian forces exemplified "Ludwig’s maneuvers"—a calculated provocation to justify war while maintaining plausible deniability. The public framing of Prussian military exercises as defensive posturing obscured the deliberate escalation toward conflict.
- The Weimar Republic (1919–1933): Germany’s economic and military constraints under the Treaty of Versailles led to clandestine rearmament programs, such as the Reichswehr’s secret maneuvers in the Rhineland. These exercises served as both a test of military readiness and a psychological probe to assess Allied responses, embodying the phrase’s duality of deception and preparation.
- The Cuban Missile Crisis (1962): While not German-specific, the U.S.-Soviet standoff over nuclear deployment in Cuba paralleled the phrase’s logic. Public declarations of "peaceful intentions" masked covert naval blockades and intelligence-gathering operations, akin to "Ludwig’s" simultaneous feints and real deployments.
Psychological Warfare and the Signal of Hidden Intentions
The phrase’s power lies in its ambiguity—it suggests movement without clarifying direction, creating uncertainty that forces adversaries to react defensively. In diplomatic contexts, this ambiguity serves several psychological purposes:- Forced Overreaction: By simulating military activity (e.g., troop redeployments near borders), a state can provoke preemptive concessions from rivals. The Weimar Republic’s 1936 remilitarization of the Rhineland leveraged this tactic, compelling France and Britain to adopt a passive stance despite violating the Treaty of Versailles.
- Bluffing and Credibility: The phrase implies a gamble—if the adversary cannot distinguish between a genuine threat and a bluff, they may either overcommit resources or retreat prematurely. Bismarck’s use of "Ludwig’s" maneuvers in 1870 relied on this dynamic, ensuring France’s miscalculation of Prussian resolve.
- Bargaining Leverage: In negotiations, the threat of "marching into maneuvers" (e.g., economic sanctions, cyberattacks) can be withdrawn in exchange for concessions. The 2014 Ukrainian crisis saw Russia employ similar tactics, with military "exercises" near the border serving as a coercive tool to influence EU policy.
Comparative Analysis: Overt Diplomacy vs. Covert Operations
The table below contrasts the phrase’s application in public statements versus clandestine operations, illustrating how its meaning shifts based on context:| Aspect | Overt Diplomacy (Public Statements) | Covert Operations (Secret Treaties/Espionage) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Tool | Treaties, speeches, joint declarations | Intelligence networks, false-flag operations, proxy forces |
| Example | Bismarck’s 1870 proclamation of Prussian neutrality (masking mobilization) | Weimar-era Reichswehr collaboration with Freikorps for clandestine training |
| Psychological Effect | Creates perception of inevitability (e.g., "Germany is unified") | Induces paranoia or misdirection (e.g., Soviet "friendly" maneuvers near NATO borders) |
| Risk of Exposure | Low (diplomatic immunity, public relations control) | High (leaks, defections, technical surveillance) |
| Modern Equivalent | "Strategic patience" (e.g., U.S. containment policy) | Cyber "attribution games" (e.g., Stuxnet, SolarWinds) |
Modern Equivalents: "Signaling" and "Strategic Ambiguity" in Contemporary Diplomacy
The phrase’s core mechanism—conveying intent without full disclosure—resonates in modern diplomatic lexicon:- Strategic Signaling: States use ambiguous actions (e.g., naval patrols near disputed waters, cyber probes) to signal resolve without committing to conflict. China’s 2013 "Air Defense Identification Zone" over the East China Sea functioned as a "Ludwig" maneuver, forcing the U.S. to respond without clarity on Beijing’s red lines.
- Strategic Ambiguity: Retaining ambiguity about capabilities (e.g., North Korea’s nuclear posture) mirrors the phrase’s deception. The lack of explicit threats or guarantees forces adversaries to speculate, creating uncertainty that can be exploited in negotiations.
- Hybrid Warfare: Modern "Ludwig" tactics blend conventional and unconventional methods. Russia’s annexation of Crimea in 2014 combined military "exercises" with pro-Russian militias, obscuring direct state involvement while achieving territorial gains.
Fictional Application: "Ludwig’s Maneuvers" in a Diplomatic Thriller
In a geopolitical thriller, the phrase could describe a state’s covert influence campaigns structured as follows:- The Setup: A European nation (e.g., Germany) stages a series of military drills near a neighboring country’s borders, framing them as routine training. Simultaneously, its intelligence services infiltrate opposition groups in the target state, planting disinformation about impending attacks.
- The Bluff: When the target state demands explanations, Germany’s foreign minister dismisses the exercises as defensive, while secretly escalating cyberattacks on critical infrastructure. The ambiguity forces the target to choose between escalation (risking war) or capitulation (losing face).
- The Payoff: The crisis is "resolved" through a backroom deal—e.g., the target state abandons a trade agreement or allows German corporate access to its markets. The phrase "Ludwig" becomes a metaphor for the entire operation: a mix of overt posturing and covert manipulation, where the true "march" is not military but political domination.
Key Narrative Devices:
Satire, Pop Culture, and Modern Usage of "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht": From Cabaret to Digital Media
The phrase "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht" has transcended its military origins to become a staple of German satire, comedy, and pop culture. Its ability to encapsulate hidden motives, strategic deception, and political maneuvering makes it a versatile tool for humorists, writers, and digital creators. Below, its evolution in comedy, idiomatic parallels, gaming adaptations, cross-cultural comparisons, satirical journalism, and internet culture is examined through structured analysis.
Satirical and Comedic References in German Theater, Cabaret, and Stand-Up
The phrase’s ambiguity and historical weight have made it a recurring motif in German comedy, particularly in Karl Valentin’s slapstick routines and Loriot’s observational humor. Valentin, a Bavarian comedian, often used military metaphors to critique authority, while Loriot employed the phrase in sketches to highlight bureaucratic absurdity. Modern stand-up comedians, such as Atze Schröder or Hape Kerkeling, reference "Ludwig" in sketches about political doublespeak, where leaders’ "maneuvers" are exposed as empty gestures.
Key Examples:
German Idioms and Proverbs Conveying Hidden Motives or Strategic Deception
German language offers numerous proverbs and idioms that parallel "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht" in conveying deception or indirect strategy. Below is a comparative list, including origins and modern usage:| Idiom/Proverb | Literal Meaning | Origin/Context | Modern Usage Example |
|---|---|---|---|
"Etwas im Schilde führen" |
"To have something in the shield" | 16th-century military slang; refers to plotting behind a shield’s cover. | Used in politics: "Die Opposition führt etwas im Schilde" ("The opposition is plotting something"). |
"Die Fassade aufrechterhalten" |
"To maintain the facade" | 19th-century architectural metaphor; implies superficial harmony. | Corporate scandals: "Trotz Skandalen hält das Unternehmen die Fassade aufrecht." ("Despite scandals, the company maintains its facade.") |
"Mit Samthandschuhen anfassen" |
"To handle with velvet gloves" | 18th-century aristocratic euphemism for indirect manipulation. | Diplomacy: "Die Regierung fasst das Thema mit Samthandschuhen an." ("The government handles the issue delicately.") |
"Ein falsches Spiel spielen" |
"To play a false game" | 17th-century card-game reference; implies deceitful strategy. | Business: "Der Konkurrent spielt ein falsches Spiel." ("The competitor is playing dirty.") |
Adaptation in German Board Games, Video Games, and Role-Playing Scenarios
The phrase’s strategic connotations lend it to game mechanics where players must infer hidden motives. In board games, it could appear as a special ability (e.g., "When Ludwig moves, opponents must declare their true intentions"); in video games, it might trigger dialogue trees where characters hint at deception. Role-playing games (RPGs) could use it as a plot device, such as:Example Games:
Comparison of Usage in German vs. English-Language Media
While "Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht" is uniquely German, its core idea—hidden strategic intent—appears in English media through different phrases. A comparative breakdown:| German Phrase | English Equivalent | Media Example (German) | Media Example (English) |
|---|---|---|---|
"Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht" |
"When the big guns roll out" | TV Series "Babylon Berlin": Police uncover hidden political maneuvers. | Film "The Social Network": Mark Zuckerberg’s "maneuvers" to outmaneuver rivals. |
"Etwas im Schilde führen" |
"Something’s brewing" | Comedy "Stromberg": Satirical take on corporate "plotting." | TV Show "The West Wing": Political operatives hinting at "backroom deals." |
"Die Fassade aufrechterhalten" |
"Keeping up appearances" | Film "Das Leben der Anderen": Stasi maintaining a facade of legitimacy. | Film "The Wolf of Wall Street": Jordan Belfort’s performative success. |
Satirical News Segments Critiquing Political or Corporate Behavior
A satirical news sketch could use "Ludwig" to expose hypocrisy by framing leaders as puppeteers pulling strings. Example structure:1. Anchor: "Heute Abend: Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht—und die Bürger merken es erst zu spät." ("Tonight: When Ludwig maneuvers—and citizens only notice too late.")
2. Sketch:
Real-World Parallel: German satirical shows like "ZDF Magazin Royale" or "Extra 3" frequently use military metaphors to mock political posturing.
Internet Memes and Digital Humor Highlighting Hypocrisy
On platforms like Reddit (r/Germany), Twitter (X), or Instagram, "Ludwig" appears in memes where:The journey through
Wenn Ludwig ins Manöver zieht* underscores a fundamental truth: deception is not merely a tool of war or politics but a cultural narrative woven into the fabric of German history. From the battlefields of 1870 to the digital battlegrounds of today, the phrase’s legacy endures as a testament to humanity’s perpetual dance with strategy and subterfuge. Its modern iterations—whether in diplomatic signaling, satirical memes, or military simulations—prove that the art of the maneuver remains as relevant as ever, adapting to new contexts while retaining its core essence. As nations and individuals continue to navigate complexities of power and perception, this idiom serves as a reminder that behind every apparent move lies the potential for a calculated game.Ultimately, the phrase’s power lies in its ambiguity, inviting both analysts and laypeople to question the motives behind every "maneuver." Whether invoked in a historical treatise, a political thriller, or a viral joke, it challenges observers to look beyond the surface—much like the generals and diplomats of old who once relied on its strategic weight. In an era where information is both weapon and currency, understanding its nuances offers a lens to decipher the unseen forces shaping decisions, from the boardroom to the battlefield.
Leave a Comment
Comments are moderated before appearing. The data you submit is processed according to the Privacy Policy of Ns2.